Beakspeak will be taking a short hiatus. I'm packing up my camera gear and trading the warm California sunshine for the more "seasonal" weather the Midwest has to offer. Actually, the outlook for Nebraska looks favorable, so hopefully there will be some good days out to see the various birds and wildlife the country has to offer. There isn't any snow in the forecast yet, but a little would be a welcome sight. You never know; like they say, "If you don't like the weather, wait a minute."
In the news, it's good to see that it's the season of giving, not taking. The Arctic National Wildlife Refuge will see another day without drilling. And with all the other ongoing battles—windfarms, pollution, development, logging, and the strippping of the Endangered Species Act—this shows hope that some of our elected officials are standing up to preserve the nation's wildlife and wilderness. Birds are the best indicator of the condition of the world. And considering all the struggles they're going through right now, they need all the help they can get.
I hope to be back at full swing around the end of the year. Happy holidays!
--Jason
p.s. If you feel, you're feeling too much stress from the holidays, maybe the turkey can help you survive.
The Jasper-Pulaski Fish and Wildlife Area and the tens of thousands of cranes that visit it each year are facing a looming threat from a hog factory being built near the area. In the previous entry "The Problem with Pigs at Jasper-Pulaski", I touched on a recent article that brought to light the disturbing lack of concern by the local government over the effects this operation could have on people and wildlife in the area. The project is being allowed to continue despite a 1,000-signature petition against it and Jasper-Pulaski's designation of Important Bird Area by the National Audubon Society. Residents have appealed to the State of Indiana Animal Health Board, requesting an environmental impact report be completed to assess the damage the hog factory could have on the area's residents and wildlife.
On December 7, I received a couple of emails from residents that live in the immediate area. The first from Marcella Marlatt, who also emailed me the original article I wrote about in the last post. Marcella expressed her concerns.
I'm Marcella Marlatt, and I am an adjoining landowner to the proposed site. My husband and I have lived here for 39 years. We own 80 acres of which, our shallow well will be within 75 ft. of the field where this hog farm plans to inject this manure. We have been able to have the crane migrate all around us--on our farm, right at our back door. They feel very much protected and thrive in this area!
Jasper-Pulaski Fish and Wildlife was recently honored by being designated as IBA (Important Bird Area) in November 2005. This means it is one of the most significant staging area for Sandhill Cranes in the world; in fact, virtually the entire Eastern population of the "Greater" subspecies of this bird stops at this site during fall migration! This proposed area provides necessary diurnal feeding grounds for migratory cranes to continue south.
More than 20,000 individual cranes amass in this area during the autumn season, and about 30,000 visit to watch them. The consequences of an accidental release of bacteria or toxin could have a severe impact on wildlife health.
We have major concerns from the Audubon Society who have invested decades of research and experimentation on these birds. They, along with our whole neighborhood know how important wildlife areas and wetlands are to both the cranes and human well-being.
I was appalled to read Jim Bergens' statement saying, QUOTE...."If something were to happen to these birds," Bergens said about the Whooping cranes, "they're not essential to the actual wild population." Bergens is property manager of Jasper-Pulaski area. His casual, unconcerned manner, is an insult to all the bird-lovers, and organizations around the United States. I question as to why we have him associated with such an important Wildlife Area such as this?
Later in the day, I received a second email from another resident, Karen Myers. Her email also included some strong points.
I moved here to live with my husband 6 years ago. We have a little boy and a Labrador puppy who both enjoy playing outside. Being originally from Northwestern Ontario (Canada) myself, I grew up deep in the bush with a healthy respect and admiration for nature, something I've done my best to pass on to our son.
It's interesting to note that hunters are not allowed to shoot Sandhill Cranes in our area, a fact for which I personally am very glad ...and yet an industrial farm operation is allowed to potentially destroy 500 acres of their habitat and put the lives of tens of thousands of cranes at risk with a massive operation of this size, on land adjoining an 8,000 acre State game reserve teeming with other wildlife.
The operation will be spreading tons of untreated hog sewage, potentially loaded with growth hormones, antibiotics and deadly pathogens on those 500 acres -- habitat used by all manner of wildlife species and precious feeding grounds to tens of thousands of Sandhill Cranes each year.
It's difficult to explain to a little 5 year old boy why protecting our soil, our water, our air, our forests and our precious wildlife is so important when he will be witnessing first-hand how little his own State/Country does to protect them, too.
I'm still in shock and can't quite believe the USA government and industry could heartlessly turn their backs on the wildlife in this Region without so much as even one environmental impact study to ensure no harm will come from this operation.
Thank you for hearing our story and bless you for caring.
On her personal blog, WAHM Diary, Karen covers a lot of the dangers associated with the waste and byproducts produced by pig factories. There's too much information to go into detail here, so go read it for yourself. It's quite an eye-opener.
In her email, Karen brings up a good point about what little the government is doing to protect the area. And that's what's bothering me the most. No environmental impact report has been required for this facility to be built. If a credible EIR was conducted and concluded that there would be no negative impact to the area, its inhabitants, and wildlife, then the hog factory should allowed to be continue. But it doensn't seem like anyone knows, or wants to disclose it. When the manager of Jasper-Pulaski was asked about what sort of research has been conducted, he responded "No direct research." So what are the harmful effects, and what's the mitigation plan if there are problems? Maybe the State of Indiana Animal Health Board will help to make sure those are determined.
It's also sad to see how little press this issue has received. The only article that really challenged the decision to allow this pig factory was on a website that removes its stories after a day. And where's the National Audubon Society? Shouldn't they be doing something to help protect their newly-designated Important Bird Area? I'm over 2,000 miles away from Jasper-Pulaski and I haven't been there yet, but I still feel the need to help protect it. I was raised to respect nature; I enjoy it and appreciate it. The cranes and other wildlife that enjoy, appreciate, and rely on Jasper-Pulaski could use a little help. Perhaps if this issue got more national recognition, politicians would feel more pressure to do what's right and research the problem with pigs at Jasper-Pulaski. The government wants to spread manure, but you can help the cranes by spreading the word.
While reviewing news for Fledglinks on November 21, I ran across an article about plans for a hog factory near the Jasper-Pulaski Fish & Wildlife Area in Indiana, which was designated as an Important Bird Area by the National Audubon Society on November 1. The Belstra Milling Company's 2,496-sow hog factory got the green light by Jasper County's Board of Zoning Appeals on November 14, despite the IBA designation of the area and a 1,000-signature petition against the project. Area residents have contacted the State of Indiana Animal Health Board to request an environmental impact report be completed to assess the hazards to the area's wildlife and natural habitat. About 20,000 cranes migrate through there every year.
On Tuesday, I received an email from one of the area residents that included an article from the Post-Tribune called "Hog farm ruffles haven in crane migration trek" authored by staff writer Jon Seidel. I went to their site and the article was the first story listed for the day. But the next day it was gone, with all the other stories that had been there. It's a good thing the article was sent in an email because it seems that the Post-Tribune doesn't keep archives. I emailed Seidel to find out if this article will be available again, but he responded saying it might be a couple of weeks. I'll link to it if it turns up.
It's an excellent piece, and Seidel included some quotes from the involved parties that made this whole hog factory issue a little disturbing. Belstra has the support of the Department of Natural Resources, and the DNR's Jim Bergens, the property manager of the Jasper-Pulaski area, is in charge of the welfare of the birds. Bergens has a degree in Wildlife Management from Humboldt State University in California. Didn't sound too bad, but then I read this:
The DNR recently told Bergens not to speak to reporters about the Belstra development. However, that order came after he spoke to the Post-Tribune last week.
Bergens said his opinions on the Belstra matter are based strictly on his background knowledge of the cranes and the Jasper County area. He said he has done no research on what the Belstra farm might do to the area.
"No direct research," Bergens said.
Why not talk to reporters? Is the DNR afraid something is going to come to light? Maybe they're concerned that Bergens will speak the truth. And if there hasn't been any "direct" research done, how can Bergens ensure that no harm comes to the visiting cranes? Things like this scare me. Something that could affect such and important area is being allowed to continue without a formal environmental impact report to determine what impact it could have on the surrounding area. If the EIR is done in a credible manner and shows there will be no harm, then the project should be allowed to continue. If the project goes on without a proper assessment and mitigation plan, there could be irreparable damage.
Recently, Bergens said, endangered whooping cranes have joined the migration path. Some of them have been found in Jasper County as recently as mid-November. They are part of a "nonessential experimental" project, Bergens said.
"If something were to happen to these birds," Bergens said about the whooping cranes, "they're not essential to the actual wild population."
The Whooping Crane (Grus americana) is on the federal endangered list. As of a year ago, there were a total of 468, with 213 in the wild. Their numbers are slowly climbing, but with such a small population size, no bird should be considered "not essential".
The amount of waste created by 2,496 pigs on a daily basis can add up quickly. A quick search turned up a study done on the Ontario Pork Industry. "A 2400 sow unit is projected to produce 90 litres/day/sow including offspring. This amounts to 14.4 to 17 million gallons of waste per year." That sounds like a lot to deal with. According to Belstra's Vice President, Malcolm DeKryger, the manure produced by the farm will be injected six to eight inches under the soil and they plan on using GPS to make sure the waste doesn't go where it won't cause any damage. What they fail to mention is the kinds of bacteria and drugs will be in this manure. I received an second email from another citizen who covers all the sewage dangers on her blog; more on that later.
Bergens said he is not concerned about the cranes eating the manure when they probe into the soil with their beaks for food. Most of them are eating waste grain off fields that people have already tampered with, Bergens said.
"There's fertilizer, there's all kinds of other things in the soil," Bergens said. "When they're feeding on waste grain, they're probably not probing the soil at all."
Just because other sources of food might not be ideal, it doesn't make the waste produced by the hog factory any less harmful. And the birds may not be probing the soil for food, but they'll be walking in it.
Bergens said his two-decades worth of background knowledge on the birds is enough to help him come to these conclusions.
"I've watched Jasper County develop," Bergens said. "I've watched the Sandhill crane population develop."
Also, he said, he made no absolute promises about the safety of the birds to the Board of Zoning Appeals.
It's probably a good thing he didn't make any promises since he did "no direct research". And as watching the crane population develop, you'd think he'd be more concerned with the possible dangers.
I hope this article becomes available once again. It really is worth reading as a whole. If you want to read it, email me and I'll forward it to you. The way this whole project is being allowed to progress is really disconcerting. Allowing it to go through without any sort of environmental impact assessment seems like a really bad idea. Who knows, maybe Belstra and Bergens are correct and nothing will happen. But what if they're wrong? There's too much at stake to not do the research.
As I mentioned earlier, I received emails from two of the residents that live near the developing hog factory. They have a lot of insight to provide...in the next post.
Note: The wildlife area in this article was previously referred to as "Jasper/Pulaski", but the formal name is actually "Jasper-Pulaski". The article has been updated to reflect this.